Defibrillator Case to Go to Top Court in California

Defibrillator Case to Go to Top Court in California

With more than 700 Americans dying of cardiac arrest each day, a divided federal appeals court wants the California Supreme Court to decide whether state law requires businesses to keep a defibrillator on hand, a device that might have saved the life of a 49-year-old woman who collapsed at a Target store.

A panel of the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco voted 2-1 Tuesday to ask the state's high court to decide whether a commercial property owner's legal duty to provide emergency medical aid requires the availability of a defibrillator.

The dissenting judge, Harry Pregerson, said he believes state law requires a store to meet the "insignificant burden" of owning a defibrillator, which costs $1,200, and training one or more employees in its use.

The case arose from the death of Mary Ann Verdugo, who suffered cardiac arrest while shopping in a Target store in Pico Rivera (Los Angeles County) in August 2008. She had died by the time county Fire Department paramedics reached the store.

A suit by Verdugo's mother and brother accused Target of negligently contributing to her death by failing to stock an emergency defibrillator, a product the store sells on its website.

A jolt from a defibrillator could save the lives of 30 percent of those who suffer sudden cardiac arrest, who otherwise have little chance of survival, a 2000 government report said. Nearly 300,000 Americans suffer cardiac arrest each year and only 8 percent survive, the court said.

A federal judge dismissed the suit, saying California law does not require a store to keep a defibrillator available. In reviewing the relatives' appeal, the Ninth Circuit panel said it needed guidance from the state Supreme Court, because California courts have issued varying decisions on how far a business must go to protect its patrons.

For example, Judges Marsha Berzon and Susan Graber noted, state courts have rejected claims that a restaurant should have done more than call emergency services when a customer started choking. But another court said a bar did not do enough when it merely called police after a fight broke out.


SOURCE: Bob Egelko, San Francisco Chronicle


Mission & Vision

The mission of the Sudden Cardiac Arrest (SCA) Foundation is to prevent death and disability from sudden cardiac arrest. The vision of the SCA Foundation is to increase awareness about sudden cardiac arrest and influence attitudinal and behavioral changes that will reduce mortality and morbidity from SCA.

SCA Newsletter

Sign Up with the SCA Foundation News in order to stay informed! (* required field)

Contact Us

The Sudden Cardiac Arrest Foundation would like to hear from you! If you have questions or comments — Contact Us!


Sudden Cardiac Arrest Foundation
7500 Brooktree Road
Wexford, PA 15090

Copyright © 2019 Sudden Cardiac Arrest Foundation. All Rights Reserved.

Web Design & Development, & Web Hosting By FastWebEngine